I need more records. More new records. And I definitely need a record washer. These seemingly random musings are actually key takeaways from time spent with the fabulous U-Turn Orbit Theory turntable, the brand’s new flagship that looks gorgeous and sounds even better.

Like a lot of people, my record habit over the years has often been more about a physical connection to my favorite albums than performance. Most of my dozens of records were rounded up on a shoestring budget, more as a fun hobby than out of reverence for analog media.

I did what so many of us do: resurrected my parents’ old hi-fi, added a moderately priced cartridge, and enjoyed the ritual of the needle and groove—all while keeping my spending in check. But since streaming generally offers a more practical solution, my record collection has been largely left to atrophy.

It didn’t take much time with the Theory for me to rediscover what I learned as an A/V journalist a decade ago: Vinyl done right makes all the difference. Though the Theory costs double the price of U-Turn’s next best table, it pays off with thoughtful upgrades, pristine components, and top-notch construction. This all translates into lifelike sound quality that has transformed my dusty stacks of wax into reverential musical experiences. I just can’t believe I didn’t upgrade sooner.

Setting up the belt-driven Theory takes some diligence, especially if you’re new to the experience. You’re essentially constructing it, and there are a few precarious moments—including when you add the counterweight at the end of the arm that holds the needle (technically called the “stylus”), which took me a bit to get right. I feared that I was about to drop the stylus onto the acrylic platter, which the instructions explicitly say not to do for fear of damage.

Even so, I had a record spinning in under 10 minutes, and there’s a feeling of satisfaction when it all comes together. U-Turn has also improved the experience over previous tables like its Orbit Special, with upgrades that include a dual-speed motor to swap between 33-rpm and 45-rpm records with a switch—previously you had to physically move the belt—and a belt groove in the translucent platter for better stability and easier placement.

The hardwood plinth (available in three finishes) is a sturdy base that looks both rustic and stylish. Like most components, its primary job is limiting noise by reducing unwanted resonance; the good looks are gravy.

The Theory comes with a choice of moving magnet (MM) cartridges; the default is an audiophile favorite, the Ortofon 2M Blue, but you can also upgrade to the 2M Bronze for $180. The cartridge is where the needle/stylus literally hits the groove and transduces the patterns to electrical information that becomes the music, so getting a good one is extremely important.

The Blue is beloved for a reason, and it sounds fabulous, with impressive clarity, stereo spacing, and overall instrumental definition. I was smitten with it playing through my reference 2.1 setup, including a pair of KEF LSX speakers (9/10 WIRED Recommends) and an SVS 3000 Micro sub. You’ll probably only want to upgrade to the Bronze if you’ve got a fairly high-end setup.

The other components are, for the most part, designed to get out of the way of the cartridge and stylus, allowing for pristine sound transference to your system.

The biggest piece of that equation is the new, house-built OA3 Pro tonearm. It’s a single piece molded from magnesium—a material that is known for its strength, light weight, and excellent sound damping, and it’s touted to be 10 times quieter than aluminum. You’ll see magnesium tonearms on plenty of other turntables at this price and much higher. Apart from its sonic properties, the OA3 looks cool and feels luxe when you drop it on a record.

The dual-speed motor is designed for virtually silent operation, with a controller the company claims can adjust the record speed up to 30,000 times per second for accurate playback. Even the aluminum feet are primed for maximum quiet while also making it simple to adjust the plinth for an even ride on multiple surfaces. To test its mettle, I set the table directly on the record stand, rather than my elevated table, and I only noted a couple of skips during playback.

If you don’t have a separate phono preamp and your amp lacks one, you can add U-Turn’s Pluto 2 built-in for an extra $70. That’s a deal, considering you’ll pay $100 for the Pluto 2 as an outboard pre. It’s simple to use with the press of a switch, though it is a bit awkward to reach.

I started my Orbit Theory audition with a new record I’d yet to pull out of the plastic: Absolute Loser by Fruit Bats. One of the signs of a true audiophile experience is a sensation that extends beyond the ears. By the time the stylus made its way to the title track, I had goosebumps and a big old grin.

I did notice some extra brightness with my Rolls VP29 preamp, and I found a bit more warmth in the Theory’s built-in Pluto 2. I ended up using the latter for the majority of my listening sessions. Neither one is likely to get the very best out of the Theory, and as with any link in this chain, you’ll do better with higher-quality components. If your amp has a built-in pre, you may want to do some sound comparisons to pick your favorite (just don’t use both at once).

Moving through some of my favorite vinyl, from Magical Mystery Tour to American Beauty and Elton John’s Tumbleweed Connection, I found myself taking copious notes as the music leaped out of the speakers and into my living room with an almost live presence. The Beatles’ Mystery Tour seemed to explode off the disc, cutting double vocals with crystalline precision, melting analog synthesizers in psychedelic flames, and pushing forth warm and crunchy horns and mournful cellos that seemed to vibrate in my chest.

Tumbleweed was a stirring cowboy melodrama, as Elton’s vocals popped out front with diamond clarity and his piano rang with the woody glimmer of an old honky-tonk. Cymbals puffed with shimmering resonance, strings swelled, and thumpy bass and guitar bounced across the wide and dimensional soundstage.

With almost every record I spun over the next few days, the instruments and vocals seemed to carve out three-dimensional images in front of me, as though building a live band in the air. I detected little to no distortion or timing issues across multiple records, even with some of my flimsier aftermarket pressings.

I did find out quickly that some of my records were not quite ready for prime time. While I did my best to clean the older ones with water and a synthetic rag, I missed a few that were apparently coated with muck, and my trusty AudioQuest brush was powerless against it.

This sent me quickly to the local hi-fi store (luckily I live in Portland, which is vinyl hipster central) to get a stylus brush. You need to keep the needle ultra-clean or you’ll soon run out of clear sonic roadway; a bit of gunk took things from audiophile dream to distorted nightmare in seconds. As any dealer or enthusiast will tell you, even after you wash your older records, you have to brush them to get rid of static every play, every time.

Still, I was surprised by how many of my old records, some dug up straight from the ’60s and ’70s for just a few bucks, sounded excellent after a clean. Even with a bit of static and pop, once the music swelled, these aging time capsules were transformed from forgotten relics to musical masterpieces.

As an object, the Theory is a delight. The belt is fascinating to watch, the switch gives a satisfying click, and the tonearm is smooth as silk. The one issue is the lack of auto-return, which means you have to monitor each record closely and stop it manually after each side. This can be annoying if you’re out of the room or entertaining. But it didn’t come up much for me, as every record I played seemed to drag me in to let the sweet analog goodness wash over me.

The Theory is obviously a pricey purchase, but considering the build quality and components like the magnesium tonearm and Ortofon cartridge, the cost is justified—especially if you have a solid sound system and record collection to pair it with.

Moreover, if you’re like me and have already invested years of time, money, and effort into amassing a large-ish collection, it only makes sense to invest in a player that will make it all worthwhile. The Theory is certainly that. And it looks damn good doing it.