Hasbro, Your "Magic: The Gathering" Movie Is Murdering My Childhood
Released on 04/10/2014
(steam engine whistle)
So there's gonna be a movie based on Magic: The Gathering.
I have no words. Tap me. I'm spent.
I blame Hasbro. For everything, but especially for this.
They turned Transformers and G.I. Joe
into big movie franchises,
and now they're spending all of their mana
setting up movie deals for all of their other properties.
Tonka trucks, Stretch Armstrong, Monopoly,
Candy Land, and yes, Magic.
Hasbro brought in Simon Kinberg,
who worked on the X-Men and Fantastic Four films,
to turn Magic into a big blockbuster trilogy
a la Harry Potter or Lord of the Rings.
The Hollywood Reporter writes that Kinberg will, quote,
Act as the franchise's engineer, or Supreme Sorcerer,
if you will.
I won't, Hollywood Reporter.
I won't!
I'm trying to be open minded.
Who would've imagined that a movie based
on the Pirates of the Caribbean ride would be any good?
But the track record of movies based on tabletop games
is even worse than the track record
of movies based on video games.
Battleship,
Dungeons and Dragons,
Clue.
That bodes not well, people.
And I can't imagine that Hollywood will actually figure out
what makes Magic a great card game.
Because, surprise, it's not the backstory,
it's not the fantasy artwork on the cards,
that's just for pretty.
12 million people play Magic because of the deep
and complex play mechanics.
It's a great card game. Like Cribbage.
But play mechanics don't exactly translate
to the Syd Field screenplay template.
If Hasbro really wanted to make a good movie about Magic,
they'd tell the lightly fictionalized story
of some brilliant Magic player.
Like John Finkel.
It opens with a training montage, where he hones his skill.
Then he journeys to tournaments where he tests himself
to the utmost.
Maybe some evil counterfeiting outfit
tries to blackmail our hero into laundering a batch
of fake Black Lotus Limited Edition Alpha cards.
Oh, this thing practically writes itself.
I bet it'll come with a very weak ending,
and if you want the really good
Limited Edition Alpha ending,
you'll have to shell out a hundred bucks on eBay.
Lay your cards on the table.
What's the most you've ever spent on a CCG card?
Let me know in the comments.
Starring: Chris Baker
Bad Ideas from Hollywood: Punctuation in Titles—Age of the Colon
Why is WWE on SyFy?! Cable Networks Straying from Their Original Missions
TV Networks Are Running Out of Original Ideas
What the Bleep is Bumblebee? Indecisive Autobot Keeps Switching his Vehicular Form
Deconstructing LEGO: How a Beloved Toy Sold Out to Cross-Brand Licensing
The Inauthenticity of CG Blood and the Demise of Karo Syrup and Red Food Coloring
The Implausibility of Thor's Physics-Defying Hammer, Mjölnir
The Unraveling of Secret Societies in Pop Cultural References
The Watered-Down Hunger Games Trilogy
Giving Thanks for TV Shows That End Before Their Time
Can Ben Affleck Successfully Suit Up as the Dark Knight?
Chris Baker Responds to YouTubers About Kick-Ass 2 and the Real-Life Superheroes Trend
The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug and the Evolution of CG Dragons
Chris Baker’s Favorite Christmas Movie of All Time
Riddick and Hollywood's Failed Attempts at Using POV Cameras
The Big Bang Theory’s Shortcomings and Inaccurate Portrayal of Geek Culture
Will Disney Ruin Star Wars?
The Most Famous Female Comic Book Character is a Franchise Flop
The Unnecessary RoboCop Remake
Late Night with Seth Meyers and Stale After-Hours Talk Shows
How to Improve the Academy Awards
Mr. Peabody & Sherman and Today’s Remakes of Classic Cartoons
The Veronica Mars Movie Project and the Pitfalls of Crowdfunding Films
Fox News’ Abundant & Unnecessary Use of Big-Area Touch Screens
Captain America’s Unrealistic Vibranium Shield
The Problem with Game of Thrones
Hasbro, Your "Magic: The Gathering" Movie Is Murdering My Childhood
How Hollywood Can Get Evil Twins Right
Why Exactly Is Parkour Not a Film Genre Yet?
Networks Somehow Find Another Way to Resurrect Old Shows
The Greatest Fictional Characters Ever All in One Show? Sign Me Up
Why the New Godzilla Movie Won’t Suck
The Madness of the Timeline Mashup in the New X-Men
Why Disney Needs to Make More Movies About Classic Villains
Why Edge of Tomorrow is of the Greatest Movie About Video Games, Ever
Is Darth Disney Destroying Star Wars’ Expanded Universe?
Why Clint Eastwood’s “Jersey Boys” is Destined to Crash & Burn on the Big Screen
Death to the Superhero Comic-Book Movie … But Not All Comic-Book Movies
Why Andy Serkis is the Greatest Actor of His Generation
Give Me a Standalone Comic-Book Movie or Give Me Death
Reboots We Need Way More Than "Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles"
Brett Ratner's Hercules & Pillaging Story Lines for Big-Budget CGI Films